Monday, March 25, 2013

Double/Triple Tops - My Bread And Butter Setup (For Now)

Been so long since I last blogged, and I can only attribute it to laziness plus the desire to spend my time on other things. Anyway I've been doing a lot of reading/chart time as well as thorough planning and analysis of the kind of trader I am. I concluded that I'm someone who likes a high win rate, like 80-90%, and don't mind if these wins are small in percentage. I've realized that a trend following system often only has a <50% win rate due to the necessity of a wider stop to avoid being stop hunted or washed out by noise. I'm fully aware that a 80-90% win rate system is highly unlikely to capture big trends, though it is still possible if a trade just runs without any deep correction. Having established that and after doing a lot of visual back testing, I've decided on my bread and butter setup.

The setup is basically double or triple tops (or bottoms) with a pin/engulfing bar, divergence, and sufficient space. That's it! Here is the trade criteria and some example charts:

Trade Setup
  1. Double/Triple Top
  2. MACD Bearish Divergence
  3. Pin/Bearish Engulfing bar
  4. Fake Breakout (Optional but adds a lot more weight if it happens due to trapped traders)
  5. Confluence of the following Support/Resistance factors (The more the better)
    • Horizontal S/R
    • Fibonnaci Levels
    • Round Numbers
  6. Sufficient space for price to move into (This is very very important)
  7. Compression

Chart Examples

GBPUSD Daily
USDCAD Daily
Trade Management
This is pretty discretionary, but personally I'm trying out a strategy of taking half profits at the first trouble area, tightening my stop, and trailing the second half. It is too much to go into the details of a trouble area or the trailing method.

This setup really does have a hit rate of 90% and above, and by that I mean price should at least reach the first trouble area for us to either take half profits or tighten stops to ensure it will not become a losing trade. This setup is according to James16 the highest probability setup, and he knows of very huge account full time traders who only trade this setup. Now here is the interesting thing. This setup is also acknowledged by Alexander Elder as the strongest signal in technical analysis. Not enough? A pin bar is also a Wyckoff/VSA Spring/Upthrust, and well known Wyckoff practioner David Weis mentioned that one could make a decent living just trading these bars alone. 

I've without a shadow of doubt that this setup should be taken every single time it appears. Now admittedly it is very rare, and so I'm looking for it on the weekly, daily, 4H, and 1H time frames. Now here are the main reasons why this setup might fail: 
  1. Trading into support/resistance (Lack of space)
  2. Price action setup was too small (Small Pin/Engulfing)
  3. Failure to take partial profits or tighten stop at the first trouble area
  4. Entering on lower timeframe (1H/4H) just before major news
Avoid these pitfalls and success should be guaranteed. I'm starting my hardcore hunt for these setups, lets see how it goes. 

Btw I'm really grateful to the James16 group and especially to one of the instructors Mike who has helped me so much. In the past 2 weeks I've taken 9 trades on my demo account, 4 on my live, and none of them were losing trades. They were either wins or breakevens, though the winning trades are not huge. I am finally seeing progress in my trading, and I attribute it all to the James16 group. This group doesn't teach a system, it teaches how the market move and where price is likely to react. Based on that the members have derived many successful strategies/systems, and the beauty of it is just amazing.

Friday, February 22, 2013

What Makes A Good Trade?

Man two trades I took recently are so important that I wanted to blog about it. First we need to ask ourselves what makes a good trade? For me it is mainly two things - Good Trade Selection and Good Trade Management. When a trade ends up as a losing trade, it could be because the setup was sub optimal to begin with. In that case, the problem lies with the trade selection. Other times, it could be because we didn't manage the trade properly. This could be mistakes like not observing stop loss, or leaving too much profits on the table etc. Now this brings me to the trades I took: Capitaretail China Trust and Frasers Centerpoint Trust. So here is my trade review on both:

Capitaretail China Trust

Capitaretail China Trust
Trade Selection - Stock in steady uptrend, broke out of multi year consolidation. Ample space for price to move. Entered based on breakout of mini triangle which was consolidating with low volume. Good choice, only thing that wasn't nice was the poor liquidity of the stock.

Trade Management - Prices initially broke out nicely but closed below the breakout level with a big bearish bar. Decided to cut out for a 0.3R loss. Good management, a genuine breakout shouldn't close back below the breakout level.

Frasers Centerpoint Trust

Frasers Centerpoint Trust
Trade Selection - Stock in stead uptrend, broke out of long consolidation. All time high so no resistance above at all. Vol pattern speaks of accumulation. Entered based on a breakout of the consolidation highs. Very good selection, can't find anything wrong with it at all.

Trade Management - Prices initially broke out nicely but then formed a giant two bar reversal. This is also a two day pin bar. I was contemplating to cut out if prices hit 1 tick below the bearish bar due to the sheer size of the bar, but decided to wait and observe how price would behave if it tests the breakout level. Prices shot through that level and showed no signs of rebounding, so I ended up cutting for a 0.5R loss. Trade management could have been better as I should have cut out at 2.03 when there were no signs of interested buyers for a long time. Instead I only cut out at 2.02 when prices pulled even deeper. Nevertheless, it was good that I didn't hold on to the trade and wait for a full bar loss, as prices subsequently dived even deeper.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

So my point is this - A losing trade is not a bad trade!! If after the trade we have no regrets about the way we chose and managed the trade, it is a good trade! A bad trade is one which has a sub optimal setup or one that is poorly managed. In this case I'm very happy with my Capitaretail China Trust trade, I would have taken it all over again and managed it exactly the same way. As for Frasers Centerpoint, I would also have taken it all over again, but I would have cut out at a higher price, so well the trade management was a little lacklustre.

In both cases, what if prices shot back up without me? Well, that is something I have to accept, and I'm totally willing to accept it. To me, a good breakout shouldn't go too deep back below the breakout level. Sure it may test it, but it shouldn't close below it or go too deep. That is my belief, and so my management strategy is based on that belief. Also, one could be wondering, why didn't I take partial profits for both trades? Well, this is because there was completely no reason to do so. Price wasn't at any trouble area, there was complete open space above, and I'm comfortable with pullbacks as that is a natural thing. Of course in hindsight taking partial profits would have worked out better, but again I have no regrets and would still have chosen to hold on to the full position all over again.

Am I sore about the losses? A little for sure, but I have totally no regrets in taking these small losses. In fact, the way I managed them is exactly in line with "keep your losses small". I had two losses but it only cost me 0.8R instead of 2R had I waited for full bar losses. This is something so essential that I learned from James16. If the premise for your trade has been invalidated (In this case price closing back below the breakout level), simply cut out and take a small loss.

Sunday, February 17, 2013

The Importance Of Levels

Finally back to posting after so long! Well I've been real occupied with a lot of deep diving into the James16 material, and honestly I'm getting more and more impressed. The quality of the material and members is truly incredible and unbelievable. It is hard to imagine another better place to learn price action. One could just pay USD 129 to get access for a month and walk away with material which in my opinion is worth 10k or more. And no, I'm just a satisfied customer and is in no way affiliated with them :)

So anyway, I want to blog about something that has been on my mind a lot lately. It is about levels. I read this in a forum thread recently and it really got me thinking:

Now that is not to say that trading candlesticks is not a viable strategy. I still use them (particularly on the daily time frame) to gauge potential market direction.

However, after discussions with other successful traders, I began to distrust them in terms of entries one side and stops the other. 

Let's look at this in a little more detail.

A bullish pin, by way of example, simply shows that demand has come in at a level. However, the fact that buyers came in does NOT mean that buyers will continue bidding prices up. I started to think of a candlestick pattern in the same way I thought of an indicator: it lags.

If you think of the market moves as having a cause and effect relationship, the cause of a move is the market participants that interact at the areas of perceived value (or lack of it), the effect is the resulting candlestick. 

Now I would sit there waiting for setups and I would say to the other traders: "I'm waiting for confirmation" but what I didn't realise is that by trading the effect and not the cause, you are always one step behind the market. 

So, the aim became to pinpoint an entry at an area that will cause other traders to follow you which can then create the effect of favourable momentum, meaning that still more traders join later and the momentum continues.


There are a few other important points to make about candlestick patterns.

Firstly, if price trades into a significant technical level, the probability shifts in favour of a reaction as the limit orders get hit from those traders entering and exiting the market. However, the duration of that reaction is unknown. Or to put it in laymans terms: it's one thing to accept that price will react to a key support level but it's another thing entirely when you have to work out how far it will travel in your favour. The simple fact is: if you enter at the source of the move rather than after the reaction, you have more options in the event there is no follow through from the other market participants.

This leads me onto my second point. The "entry" of the pin itself is usually at a random price. This then poses a problem for those traders that love to get their stops to "break even" because the majority of the time, their break even price means absolutely nothing to the market. 

This loosely leads me onto my third point. Candlesticks have an open and a close. The forex market does not. All candlesticks do, is break the market movement down into convenient "slices" of time but it is important to realise that the market does not stop moving. This therefore means that a "setup" can be dependent on a completely arbitrary concept such as the time your broker considers to be the "close". 

Perhaps worse than this, is the fact that you can miss a level that price has an extremely high probability of bouncing at simply because you failed to get a pretty candlestick that has just the right length wick and just the right size body to tuck it nicely within the previous candle within the window of time that you chose.

Now that is something that is really deep. While the author is trying to substantiate his trading style, what spoke to me was the importance of levels. Here is in my opinion how price action (PA) traders should progress:

  1. New traders start off being focused on PA setups like pin bars or engulfing bars. They trade them all over the charts, into trouble areas, against the trend, and inevitably gets burned.
  2. Once they realize the mistakes they're making, they become more picky and only trade setups at strong confluence levels with nice big PA bars and good space.
  3. After years of experience, these traders have become so proficient at identifying key support/resistance levels that they do not even require PA setups at these levels. They can take touch trades off them or simply drop down to a lower time frame to refine their entries.
Now this is very powerful because touch trades allow one to get in before PA traders do with the benefit of a very tight stop. Obviously, new traders will get killed trying to trade like this because of their inability to identify true significant levels. However, whats there to stop experienced traders from doing so? It is too much to go in depth into such a trading style, one could study Jarroo from the public James16 thread. I've spent the past few days studying his material (lots of videos from the private group) and I must say it is truly ingenious and pure.

Personally, I'm still going to trade PA setups until I've achieved substantial success with them. However, I'll be paying a lot more attention to key levels and how prices behave around them. In fact, I'll strive to only take PA setups off these levels. 


Sunday, January 13, 2013

What Is Success To You?

I've no idea what is going to be in this post, but I have this sudden urge to write and pen out the river of thoughts streaming in my mind. So, I was watching some YouTube videos and somehow it got me thinking about life and purpose. Maybe I should start by sharing some YouTube channels which I frequent.
These people did not start off as pop stars, they were simply people who enjoyed music. I've seen how much the quality of their videos and music have improved over the years. There is something about watching people do what they love. Passion and joy seeps out of them, it infects any beholder and touches the soul. It is hard to put into words something that is non tangible and to a certain extent, spiritual. These people do not stay still, they constantly work at their craft, they do not set limits, they continually exceed themselves.

Needless to say there is a parallel to be drawn with our trading, but I will not go there. Instead, I want to raise the timeless question "What is success to you?" All of us will have different answers when confronted with that question, and our response to it will define the way we lead our lives. Is it wealth and status? Is it family harmony? Is it about doing something you like? Is it about helping others?

The thing is, very often we start down one path but get sucked into the distractions of this world and end up on another. For example, a man may be family oriented and is contented with family harmony. However due to the tainted beliefs of the society, he is led into believing that family harmony is only possible with wealth. He stumbles down the road of corruption and immorality in order to achieve that means, ironically destroying his family in the process. How about the girl who loves music and defines success as being able to produce and share her music with the world? She starts off full of zeal, but after numerous setbacks and rejections decides that it is hard to make a living as a musician. She dumps her dream and settles for a dull office job, as a result being plagued by regret and lethargy every single day of her life.

"What is success to you?" When you're able to answer that question, do not forget the answer, come what may. Do not let the world stop you, do not let disappointments and failures stop you, do not ever lose your focus. Is wealth and status really what you desire, or is it just the means to something? What then when you've made more money than you could ever spend? I've given it much thought and I know why I want to be rich. Wealth is not my dream, it is simply the means to my dream. I've chosen trading as the means to obtain wealth, but it is because I love it. It may not be producing the results I desire yet, but I must keep pressing on and perfect my craft.

I'm reading the book "Think And Grow Rich" by Napolean Hill. The first few pages have already blew me away, invoking goosebumps upon goosebumps even as I was reading it on the train. If the rest of the book is going to be that good, I'm going to strongly recommend it as a MUST READ book for anyone who doesn't want to be a drifter in life. I'm not going to go into the content of what I've read, I just want to say that in life there are many timeless truths and wisdom that have been uncovered by great men of the past. We do not need to grope in darkness and try to figure our way in this maze where the destination is success. If there is something common that resonates in all successful people, shouldn't we strive to study and emulate it in order to hasten our journey to success?

Saturday, January 12, 2013

Awesome Forum Thread

Just want to share a forum post that is filled with so much gems of trading wisdom I got goosebumps reading it:

http://www.forexfactory.com/showthread.php?p=1432221#post1432221

Sunday, January 6, 2013

Wick Play + GBP/USD Analysis

My goodness I just came across something on the James16 group that blew my mind away. Pin bars (Aka hammers, upthrusts/springs, pinocchio bars) have been the bread and butter of my trading recently, and  it is very easy to simply interpret a pin bar with a lower tail as bullish and that with an upper tail as bearish. What if this is not necessarily true? There is a strategy known as the Wick Play on the James16 group which in short is about fading the pin bar. In other words, we long a bearish pin and short a bullish pin. Shocking? I must say the basis behind this is so good and it opened my eyes to a new level of price action analysis. I shouldn't go into the details of this strategy, but the key is to analyze the location of the pin bar.

I'm reminded that every single setup out there is about location. Where did your favorite setup form? Is your bullish engulfing just under resistance in a downtrend? I feel so thrilled to learn about the Wick Play because even though I'll not be trading it (This is definitely something only for the pros), it gives me confidence to hold on to my trades even if an opposing pin forms. So say I'm short and a bullish pin formed at a non support area, I do not need to freak out and close my trade immediately. Heck there is even a strategy to short that pin! Also, I am better able to differentiate between good pin bars and bad pin bars.

Here is (in my noob opinion) a potential candidate for the Wick Play:

GBP/USD Daily
At first glance it appears that there is a bullish pin bar. Already I see people screaming long on public forums. Take a closer look. Prices just broke down a mini double top. On the weekly chart GBP/USD is a huge bearish outside bar with no near strong support. Would you want to long this pin bar? I already know some experienced traders who're looking to short a retracement instead. To add perspective, lets look at the 4H chart.

GBP/USD 4H
The pin bar on the daily chart is simply a pullback to broken support turned resistance on the 4H chart!! Now indeed prices might go higher; it is approaching the uptrend line, at a big round number of 1.6, there is some Fib confluence etc, but is this a high probability setup? In my opinion definitely not! I used to go around trading setups blindly, these days I'm more careful as to where the setups occur and how the chart looks like on a higher time frame. It is all about location, location, location.

Saturday, January 5, 2013

A+ Setup On USD/ZAR

USD/ZAR Daily
This is in my opinion an A+ setup. Long tailed bearish pin at a significant support turned resistance level with sufficient space to move. These are what I'm trying to look for nowadays, setups which just jump at my face, which I don't need to squint and justify myself taking. There is one problem with this pair though, it is an exotic pair with a 80+ pips spread, hence rendering it untradable. =P